| 2026 | Winner | Murderland: Crime and Bloodlust in the Time of Serial Killers | Caroline Fraser | Penguin Press |
| 2026 | Finalist | Blood and the Badge: The Mafia, Two Killer Cops, and a Scandal That Shocked the Nation | Michael Cannell | Unknown |
| 2026 | Finalist | Out of the Woods: A Girl, a Killer, and a Lifelong Struggle to Find the Way Home | Gregg Olsen | Unknown |
| 2026 | Finalist | Story of a Murder: The Wives, the Mistress, and Dr. Crippen | Hallie Rubenhold | Unknown |
| 2026 | Finalist | They Poisoned the World: Life and Death in the Age of Forever Chemicals | Mariah Blake | Crown |
| 2025 | Winner | The Infernal Machine: A True Story of Dynamite, Terror, and the Rise of the Modern Detective | Steven Johnson | Random House |
| 2025 | Finalist | A Devil Went Down to Georgia: Race, Power, Privilege, and the Murder of Lita McClinton | Deb Miller Landau | Unknown |
| 2025 | Finalist | Hell Put to Shame: The 1921 Murder Farm Massacre and the Horror of America's Second Slavery | Earl Swift | Unknown |
| 2025 | Finalist | Long Haul: Hunting the Highway Serial Killers | Frank Figliuzzi | Unknown |
| 2025 | Finalist | The Amish Wife: Unraveling the Lies, Secrets, and Conspiracy that Let a Killer Go Free | Gregg Olsen | Unknown |
| 2025 | Finalist | The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age | Michael Wolraich | Unknown |
| 2024 | Winner | Crooked: The Roaring '20s Tale of a Corrupt Attorney General, a Crusading Senator, and the Birth of the American Political Scandal | Nathan Masters | Unknown |
| 2024 | Finalist | I Know Who You Are: How An Amateur DNA Sleuth Unmasked the Golden State Killer and Changed Crime Fighting Forever | Barbara Rae-Venter | Unknown |
| 2024 | Finalist | In Light of All Darkness: Inside the Polly Klaas Kidnapping and the Search for America's Child | Kim Cross | Unknown |
| 2024 | Finalist | Number Go Up: Inside Crypto's Wild Rise and Staggering Fall | Zeke Faux | Unknown |
| 2024 | Finalist | Tangled Vines: Power, Privilege, and the Murdaugh Family Murders | John Glatt | Unknown |
| 2024 | Finalist | The Lost Sons of Omaha: Two Young Men in an American Tragedy | Joe Sexton | Simon & Schuster |
| 2023 | Winner | Tell Me Everything: The Story of a Private Investigation | Erika Krouse | Unknown |
| 2023 | Finalist | American Caliph: The True Story of a Muslim Mystic, a Hollywood Epic, and the 1977 Siege of Washington, D.C. | Shahan Mufti | Farrar, Straus and Giroux |
| 2023 | Finalist | American Demon: Eliot Ness and the Hunt for America's Jack the Ripper | Daniel Stashower | Unknown |
| 2023 | Finalist | Slenderman: Online Obsession, Mental Illness, and the Violent Crime of Two Midwestern Girls | Kathleen Hale | Unknown |
| 2023 | Finalist | Trailed: One Woman's Quest to Solve the Shenandoah Murders | Kathryn Miles | Unknown |
| 2022 | Winner | Last Call: A True Story of Love, Lust, and Murder in Queer New York | Elon Green | Unknown |
| 2022 | Finalist | Sleeper Agent: The Atomic Spy in America Who Got Away | Ann Hagedorn | Simon & Schuster |
| 2022 | Finalist | The Confidence Men: How Two Prisoners of War Engineered the Most Remarkable Escape in History | Margalit Fox | Unknown |
| 2022 | Finalist | The Dope: The Real History of the Mexican Drug Trade | Benjamin T. Smith | W. W. Norton |
| 2022 | Finalist | Two Truths and a Lie: A Murder, a Private Investigator, and Her Search for Justice | Ellen McGarrahan | Unknown |
| 2022 | Finalist | When Evil Lived in Laurel: The "White Knights" and the Murder of Vernon Dahmer | Curtis Wilkie | W. W. Norton |
| 2021 | Winner | Death in Mud Lick: A Coal Country Fight Against the Drug Companies that Delivered the Opioid Epidemic | Eric Eyre | Unknown |
| 2021 | Finalist | Blood Runs Coal: The Yablonski Murders and the Battle for the United Mine Workers of America | Mark A. Bradley | W. W. Norton |
| 2021 | Finalist | The Third Rainbow Girl: The Long Life of a Double Murder in Appalachia | Emma Copley Eisenberg | Unknown |
| 2021 | Finalist | Veritas: A Harvard Professor, a Con Man and the Gospel of Jesus's Wife | Ariel Sabar | Unknown |
| 2021 | Finalist | Yellow Bird: Oil, Murder, and a Woman's Search for Justice in Indian Country | Sierra Crane Murdoch | Random House |
| 2020 | Winner | The Less People Know About Us: A Mystery of Betrayal, Family Secrets, and Stolen Identity | Axton Betz-Hamilton | Unknown |
| 2020 | Finalist | American Predator: The Hunt for the Most Meticulous Serial Killer of the 21st Century | Maureen Callahan | Unknown |
| 2020 | Finalist | Indecent Advances: A Hidden History of True Crime and Prejudice Before Stonewall | James Polchin | Counterpoint |
| 2020 | Finalist | Norco '80: The True Story of the Most Spectacular Bank Robbery in American History | Peter Houlahan | Counterpoint |
| 2020 | Finalist | The Ghosts of Eden Park: The Bootleg King, the Women Who Pursued Him, and the Murder that Shocked Jazz-Age America | Karen Abbott | Unknown |
| 2019 | Winner | Tinderbox: The Untold Story of the Up Stairs Lounge Fire and the Rise of Gay Liberation | Robert W. Fieseler | Unknown |
| 2019 | Finalist | I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer | Michelle McNamara | Harper |
| 2019 | Finalist | Sex Money Murder: A Story of Crack, Blood, and Betrayal | Jonathan Green | W. W. Norton |
| 2019 | Finalist | The Feather Thief: Beauty, Obsession, and the Natural History Heist of the Century | Kirk Wallace Johnson | Hutchinson |
| 2019 | Finalist | The Good Mothers: The True Story of the Women Who Took on the World's Most Powerful Mafia | Alex Perry | Unknown |
| 2019 | Finalist | The Last Wild Men of Borneo: A True Story of Death and Treasure | Carl Hoffman | Unknown |
| 2018 | Winner | Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI | David Grann | Doubleday |
| 2018 | Finalist | American Fire: Love, Arson, and Life in a Vanishing Land | Monica Hesse | Unknown |
| 2018 | Finalist | Mrs. Sherlock Holmes: The True Story of New York City's Greatest Female Detective and the 1917 Missing Girl Case that Captivated a Nation | Brad Ricca | St. Martin's Press |
| 2018 | Finalist | The Man From the Train: The Solving of a Century-Old Serial Killer Mystery | Bill James | Unknown |
| 2018 | Finalist | The Man From the Train: The Solving of a Century-Old Serial Killer Mystery | Rachel McCarthy James | Unknown |
| 2018 | Finalist | The Road to Jonestown: Jim Jones and Peoples Temple | Jeff Guinn | Simon & Schuster |
| 2017 | Winner | The Wicked Boy: The Mystery of a Victorian Child Murderer | Kate Summerscale | Unknown |
| 2017 | Finalist | Morgue: A Life in Death | Dr. Vincent diMaio | St. Martin's Press |
| 2017 | Finalist | Morgue: A Life in Death | Ron Franscell | St. Martin's Press |
| 2017 | Finalist | Pretty Jane and the Viper of Kidbrooke Lane: A True Story of Victorian Law and Disorder: The Unsolved Murder that Shocked Victorian England | Paul Thomas Murphy | Pegasus Books |
| 2017 | Finalist | The Lynching: The Epic Courtroom Battle that Brought Down the Klan | Laurence Leamer | Unknown |
| 2017 | Finalist | While the City Slept: A Love Lost to Violence and a Young Man's Descent into Madness | Eli Sanders | Unknown |
| 2016 | Winner | Whipping Boy: The Forty-Year Search for My Twelve-Year-Old Bully | Allen Kurzweil | Unknown |
| 2016 | Finalist | American Pain: How a Young Felon and his Ring of Doctors Unleashed America's Deadliest Drug Epidemic | John Temple | Unknown |
| 2016 | Finalist | Forensics: What Bugs, Burns, Prints, DNA and More Tell Us About Crime | Val McDermid | Unknown |
| 2016 | Finalist | Operation Nemesis: The Assassination Plot that Avenged the Armenian Genocide | Eric Bogosian | Unknown |
| 2016 | Finalist | Where the Bodies Were Buried: Whitey Bulger and the World That Made Him | T.J. English | Unknown |
| 2015 | Winner | Tinseltown: Murder, Morphine, and Madness at the Dawn of Hollywood | William Mann | Unknown |
| 2015 | Finalist | Kitty Genovese: The Murder, the Bystanders, the Crime that Changed America | Kevin Cook | W. W. Norton |
| 2015 | Finalist | Savage Harvest: A Tale of Cannibals, Colonialism, and Michael Rockefeller's Tragic Quest for Primitive Art | Carl Hoffman | Unknown |
| 2015 | Finalist | The Mad Sculptor: The Maniac, the Model, and the Murder That Shook the Nation | Harold Schechter | Unknown |
| 2015 | Finalist | The Other Side: A Memoir | Lacy M. Johnson | Tin House |
| 2014 | Winner | The Hour of Peril: The Secret Plot to Murder Lincoln Before the Civil War | Daniel Stashower | Unknown |
| 2014 | Finalist | Duel with the Devil: The True Story of how Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr Teamed Up to Take on America's First Sensational Murder Mystery | Paul Collins | Crown |
| 2014 | Finalist | Mortal Sins: Sex, Crime, and the Era of Catholic Scandal | Michael D'Antonio | Unknown |
| 2014 | Finalist | The Good Nurse: A True Story of Medicine, Madness and Murder | Charles Graeber | Unknown |
| 2014 | Finalist | The Secret Rescue: An Untold Story of American Nurses and the Medics Behind Nazi Lines | Cate Lineberry | Unknown |
| 2013 | Winner | Midnight in Peking: How the Murder of a Young Englishwoman Haunted the Last Days of Old China | Paul French | Unknown |
| 2013 | Finalist | Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America | Gilbert King | Harper |
| 2013 | Finalist | Double Cross: The True Story of the D-Day Spies | Ben Macintyre | Crown |
| 2013 | Finalist | More Forensics and Fiction: Crime Writers' Morbidly Curious Questions Expertly Answered | D.P. Lyle, MD | Unknown |
| 2013 | Finalist | The People Who Eat Darkness: The True Story of a Young Woman Who Vanished from the Streets of Tokyo - and the Evil that Swallowed Her Up | Richard Lloyd Parry | Farrar, Straus and Giroux |
| 2012 | Winner | Destiny of the Republic: A Tale of Madness, Medicine and the Murder of a President | Candice Millard | Vintage Books |
| 2012 | Finalist | Girl, Wanted: The Chase for Sarah Pender | Steve Miller | Unknown |
| 2012 | Finalist | The Man in the Rockefeller Suit: The Astonishing Rise and Spectacular Fall of a Serial Imposter | Mark Seal | Unknown |
| 2012 | Finalist | The Murder of the Century: The Gilded Age Crime that Scandalized a City and Sparked the Tabloid Wars | Paul Collins | Unknown |
| 2012 | Finalist | The Savage City: Race, Murder and a Generation on the Edge | T.J. English | Unknown |
| 2011 | Winner | Scoreboard, Baby: A Story of College Football, Crime and Complicity | Ken Armstrong, Nick Perry | Unknown |
| 2011 | Finalist | Finding Chandra: A True Washington Murder Mystery | Scott Higham, Sari Horwitz | Unknown |
| 2011 | Finalist | Hellhound on his Trail: The Stalking of Martin Luther King, Jr. and the International Hunt for his Assassin | Hampton Sides | Unknown |
| 2011 | Finalist | The Eyes of Willie McGee: A Tragedy of Race, Sex, and Secrets in Jim Crow South | Alex Heard | HarperCollins |
| 2011 | Finalist | The Killer of Little Shepherds: A True Crime Story and the Birth of Forensic Science | Douglas Starr | Knopf |
| 2010 | Winner | Columbine | Dave Cullen | Unknown |
| 2010 | Finalist | Go Down Together: The True, Untold Story of Bonnie and Clyde | Jeff Guinn | Simon & Schuster |
| 2010 | Finalist | Provenance: How a Con Man and a Forger Rewrote the History of Modern Art | Laney Salisbury, Aly Sujo | Penguin Press |
| 2010 | Finalist | The Fence: A Police Cover-Up Along Bostons Racial Divide | Dick Lehr | HarperCollins |
| 2010 | Finalist | Vanished Smile: The Mysterious Theft of Mona Lisa | R.A. Scotti | Unknown |
| 2009 | Winner | American Lightning: Terror, Mystery, the Birth of Hollywood and the Crime of the Century | Howard Blum | Unknown |
| 2009 | Finalist | For the Thrill of It: Leopold, Loeb and the Murder that Shocked Chicago | Simon Baatz | HarperCollins |
| 2009 | Finalist | Havana Nocturne: How the Mob Owned Cuba and Then Lost it to the Revolution | T.J. English | Unknown |
| 2009 | Finalist | The Man Who Made Vermeers: Unvarnishing the Legend of Master Forger Hans van Meegeren | Jonathan Lopez | Houghton Mifflin Harcourt |
| 2009 | Finalist | The Suspicions of Mr Whicher or the Murder at Road Hill House | Kate Summerscale | Unknown |
| 2008 | Winner | Reclaiming History: The Assassination of President John F. Kennedy | Vincent Bugliosi | W. W. Norton |
| 2008 | Finalist | Relentless Pursuit: A True Story of Family, Murder, and the Prosecutor Who Wouldn't Quit | Kevin Flynn | Unknown |
| 2008 | Finalist | Sacco & Vanzetti: The Men, The Murders and the Judgment of Mankind | Bruce Watson | Unknown |
| 2008 | Finalist | The Birthday Party | Stanley Alpert | Unknown |
| 2007 | Winner | Manhunt: The 12-Day Chase for Lincoln's Killer | James L. Swanson | Unknown |
| 2007 | Finalist | A Death in Belmont | Sebastian Junger | W. W. Norton |
| 2007 | Finalist | Finding Amy: A True Story of Murder in Maine | Kate Clark Flora, Joseph K. Loughlin | Unknown |
| 2007 | Finalist | Ripperology: A Study of the World's First Serial Killer | Robin Odell | Unknown |
| 2007 | Finalist | Strange Piece of Paradise | Terri Jentz | Picador |
| 2007 | Finalist | The Beautiful Cigar Girl: Mary Rogers, Edgar Allan Poe and the Invention of Murder | Daniel Stashower | Dutton |
| 2006 | Winner | Rescue Artist: A True Story of Art, Thieves, and the Hunt for a Missing Masterpiece | Edward Dolnick | HarperCollins |
| 2006 | Finalist | Desire Street: A True Story of Death and Deliverance in New Orleans | Jed Horne | Farrar, Straus and Giroux |
| 2006 | Finalist | The Elements of Murder: The History of Poison | John Emsley | Oxford University Press |
| 2006 | Finalist | True Story: Murder, Memoir, Mea Culpa | Michael Finkel | HarperCollins |
| 2006 | Finalist | Written in Blood | Diane Fanning | Unknown |
| 2005 | Winner | Conviction: Solving the Moxley Murder | Leonard Levitt | Unknown |
| 2005 | Finalist | Are You There Alone? | Suzanne O'Malley | Simon & Schuster |
| 2005 | Finalist | Ballad of the Whiskey Robber | Julian Rubinstein | Little, Brown |
| 2005 | Finalist | Forensics for Dummies | D.P. Lyle, MD | Unknown |
| 2005 | Finalist | Green River, Running Red | Ann Rule | Unknown |
| 2005 | Finalist | Ready for the People | Marissa N. Batt | Unknown |
| 2004 | Winner | The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair that Changed America | Erik Larson | Vintage Books |
| 2004 | Finalist | And The Dead Shall Rise: The Murder of Mary Phagan & the Lynching of Leo Frank | Steve Oney | Pantheon |
| 2004 | Finalist | Black Dahlia Avenger - The True Story | Steve Hodel | Unknown |
| 2004 | Finalist | Judgment Ridge: The True Story Behind the Dartmouth Murders | Dick Lehr, Mitchell Zuckoff | HarperCollins |
| 2004 | Finalist | Rothstein: The Life, Times & Murder of the Criminal Genius Who Fixed the 1919 World Series | David Pietrusza | Unknown |
| 2003 | Winner | Fire Lover | Joseph Wambaugh | William Morrow |
| 2003 | Finalist | Blood & Ink: International Guide to Fact-Based Crime Literature | Albert Borowitz | Unknown |
| 2003 | Finalist | Death at the Priory: Sex, Love and Murder in Victorian England | James Ruddick | Grove Atlantic |
| 2003 | Finalist | Takedown: The Fall of the Last Mafia Empire | Douglas Century, Rick Cowan | Unknown |
| 2003 | Finalist | The Count and the Confession | John Taylor | Random House |
| 2002 | Winner | Son of a Grifter | Kent Walker | Unknown |
| 2002 | Finalist | Base Instincts: What Makes a Killer Kill? | Jonathan H. Pincus M.D. | W. W. Norton |
| 2002 | Finalist | Dark Dreams: Sexual Violence, Homicide and the Criminal Mind | Roy Hazelwood, Stephen G. Michaud | St. Martin's Press |
| 2002 | Finalist | Leavenworth Train: A Fugitive's Search for Justice in the Vanishing West | Joe Jackson | Unknown |
| 2002 | Finalist | The Wrong Man: The Final Verdict in the Dr. Sam Sheppard Murder Case | James Neff | Random House |
| 2001 | Winner | Black Mass: The Irish Mob, The FBI, & A Devil's Deal | Dick Lehr, Gerard O'Neill | Unknown |
| 2001 | Finalist | Author Unknown: On the Trail of Anonymous | Don Foster | Henry Holt and Company |
| 2001 | Finalist | Moonlight: Abraham Lincoln & The Almanac Trial | John Evangelist Walsh | St. Martin's Press |
| 2001 | Finalist | Portraits of Guilt: The Woman Who Profiles the Faces of America's Deadliest Criminals | Jeanne Boylan | Unknown |
| 2001 | Finalist | The Seekers: A Bounty Hunter's Story | Joshua Armstrong, Anthony Bruno | HarperCollins |
| 2000 | Winner | Blind Eye | James B. Stewart | Simon & Schuster |
| 2000 | Finalist | And Never Let Her Go | Ann Rule | Simon & Schuster |
| 2000 | Finalist | Disco Bloodbath | James St. James | Simon & Schuster |
| 2000 | Finalist | Mean Justice | Edward Humes | Simon & Schuster |
| 2000 | Finalist | The Ghosts of Hopewell | Jim Fisher | Unknown |
| 1999 | Winner | To The Last Breath | Carlton Stowers | St. Martin's Press |
| 1999 | Finalist | Death Sentence | Jerry Bledsoe | Dutton |
| 1999 | Finalist | Greentown | Timothy Dumas | Unknown |
| 1999 | Finalist | One of Ours | Richard A. Serrano | W. W. Norton |
| 1999 | Finalist | Tough Jews | Rich Cohen | Simon & Schuster |
| 1998 | Winner | The Death of Innocents | Richard Firstman, Jamie Talan | Bantam Books |
| 1998 | Finalist | Bitter Harvest: A Woman's Fury, A Mother's Sacrifice | Ann Rule | Simon & Schuster |
| 1998 | Finalist | May God Have Mercy: A True Story of Crime & Punishment | John C. Tucker | W. W. Norton |
| 1998 | Finalist | Our Guys:The Glen Ridge Rape and the Secret Life of the Perfect Suburb | Bernard Lefkowitz | University of California Press |
| 1998 | Finalist | The Napoleon of Crime: The Life and Times of Adam Worth, Master Thief | Ben MacIntyre | Farrar, Straus and Giroux |
| 1997 | Winner | Power To Hurt | Darcy O'Brien | HarperCollins |
| 1997 | Finalist | Fall Guys | Jim Fisher | Unknown |
| 1997 | Finalist | No Matter How Loud I Shout | Edward Humes | Simon & Schuster |
| 1997 | Finalist | Outrage | Vincent Bugliosi | W. W. Norton |
| 1997 | Finalist | Trespasses | Howard Swindle | Viking |
| 1996 | Winner | Circumstantial Evidence | Pete Earley | Bantam Books |
| 1996 | Finalist | Born To Kill | T.J. English | Unknown |
| 1996 | Finalist | By Two and Two | Jim Schutze | Unknown |
| 1996 | Finalist | Mindhunter | John Douglas, Mark Olshaker | Unknown |
| 1996 | Finalist | Unfinished Murder | James Neff | Pocket Books |
| 1995 | Winner | To Protect and Serve | Joe Domanick | Pocket Books |
| 1995 | Finalist | Before He Wakes | Jerry Bledsoe | Dutton |
| 1995 | Finalist | Breakdown | Eileen McNamara | Pocket Books |
| 1995 | Finalist | In the Best of Families | Dennis McDougal | Warner Books |
| 1995 | Finalist | Mississippi Mud | Edward Humes | Simon & Schuster |
| 1994 | Winner | Until the Twelfth of Never | Bella Stumbo | Pocket Books |
| 1994 | Finalist | Final Justice | Steven Naifeh, Gregory White Smith | Dutton |
| 1994 | Finalist | Gone in the Night | David Protess, Rob Warden | Delacorte Press |
| 1994 | Finalist | Lindbergh: The Crime | Noel Behn | Unknown |
| 1994 | Finalist | The Misbegotten Son | Jack Olsen | Delacorte Press |
| 1993 | Winner | Swift Justice | Harry Farrell | St. Martin's Press |
| 1993 | Finalist | Blood Echoes | Thomas H. Cook | Dutton |
| 1993 | Finalist | Everything She Ever Wanted | Ann Rule | Simon & Schuster |
| 1993 | Finalist | My Husband's Trying to Kill Me | Jim Schutze | HarperCollins |
| 1993 | Finalist | The Trunk Murderess: Winnie Ruth Judd | Jana Bommersbach | Simon & Schuster |
| 1992 | Winner | Homicide: A Year on the Killing Streets | David Simon | Houghton Mifflin |
| 1992 | Finalist | Boss of Bosses: The Fall of the Godfather: The FBI and Paul Castellano | Andris Kurins, Joseph F. O'Brien | Simon & Schuster |
| 1992 | Finalist | Death of Elvis: What Really Happened | James P. Cole, Charles C. Thompson II | Delacorte Press |
| 1992 | Finalist | Den of Thieves | James B. Stewart | Simon & Schuster |
| 1992 | Finalist | Witnesses from the Grave: The Stories Bones Tell | Christopher Joyce, Eric Stover | Little, Brown |
| 1991 | Winner | In a Child's Name | Peter Maas | Simon & Schuster |
| 1991 | Finalist | A Death in White Bear Lake | Barry Siegel | Bantam Books |
| 1991 | Finalist | Beyond Reason | Ken Englade | St. Martin's Press |
| 1991 | Finalist | Goombata | John Cummings, Ernest Volkman | Little, Brown |
| 1990 | Winner | Doc: The Rape of the Town of Lovell | Jack Olsen | Atheneum |
| 1990 | Finalist | Murder in Little Egypt | Darcy O'Brien | Unknown |
| 1990 | Finalist | The Blooding: The True Story of the Narborough Village Murders | Joseph Wambaugh | Unknown |
| 1990 | Finalist | The Death Shift: The True Story of Nurse Genene Jones and the Texas Baby Murders | Peter Elkind | Viking |
| 1990 | Finalist | Wasted: The Preppie Murder | Linda Wolfe | Simon & Schuster |
| 1989 | Winner | In Broad Daylight | Harry N. MacLean | Harper & Row |
| 1989 | Finalist | A Gathering of Saints | Robert Lindsey | Simon & Schuster |
| 1989 | Finalist | Family of Spies: Inside the John Walker Spy Ring | Pete Earley | Bantam Books |
| 1989 | Finalist | Monkey on a Stick | Lindsey Gruson, John Hubner | Harcourt Brace Jovanovich |
| 1989 | Finalist | The Cocaine Wars | Paul Eddy, Hugo Sabogal, Sara Walden | W. W. Norton |
| 1988 | Winner | CBS Murders | Richard Hammer | Unknown |
| 1988 | Finalist | Dreams of Ada | Robert Mayer | Viking |
| 1988 | Finalist | Engaged to Murder | Loretta Schwartz-Noble | Viking |
| 1988 | Finalist | Talked to Death | Stephen Singular | Unknown |
| 1988 | Finalist | The Man Who Robbed the Pierre | Ira Berkow | Atheneum |
| 1987 | Winner | Careless Whispers: The True Story of a Triple Murder and the Determined Lawman Who Wouldn't Give Up | Carlton Stowers | Unknown |
| 1987 | Finalist | Incident at Big Sky: Sheriff Johnny France and the Mountain Men | Johnny France, Malcolm McConnell | W. W. Norton |
| 1987 | Finalist | The Poison Tree: A True Story of Family Violence and Revenge | Alan Prendergast | Unknown |
| 1987 | Finalist | Unveiling Claudia: A True Story of Serial Murder | Daniel Keyes | Bantam Books |
| 1987 | Finalist | Wiseguy: Life in a Mafia Family | Nicholas Pileggi | Simon & Schuster |
| 1986 | Winner | Savage Grace | Stephen M.L. Aronson, Natalie Robins | Unknown |
| 1986 | Finalist | At Mother's Request: A True Story of Money, Murder and Betrayal | Jonathan Coleman | Atheneum |
| 1986 | Finalist | Nutcracker: Money, Madness, Murder: A Family Album | Shana Alexander | Doubleday |
| 1986 | Finalist | Somebody's Husband, Somebody's Son: The Story of the Yorkshire Ripper | Gordon Burn | Viking |
| 1986 | Finalist | The Airman and the Carpenter: The Lindbergh Kidnapping and the Framing of Richard Hauptmann | Ludovic Kennedy | Viking |
| 1986 | Finalist | The Murder of a Shopping Bag Lady | Brian Kates | Harcourt Brace Jovanovich |
| 1985 | Winner | Double Play: The San Francisco City Hall Killings | Mike Weiss | Unknown |
| 1985 | Finalist | Earth to Earth | John Cornwell | Ecco |
| 1985 | Finalist | Evidence of Love: A True Story of Passion and Death in the Suburbs | Jim Atkinson, John Bloom | Unknown |
| 1985 | Finalist | Murder at the Met | David Black | Unknown |
| 1985 | Finalist | The Molineux Affair | Jane Pejsa | Unknown |
| 1984 | Winner | Very Much A Lady | Shana Alexander | Little, Brown |
| 1984 | Finalist | Deadly Force | Lawrence O'Donnell Jr. | Unknown |
| 1984 | Finalist | Judgement Day | B.C. Hall, Bob Lancaster | Unknown |
| 1984 | Finalist | Son | Jack Olsen | Atheneum |
| 1984 | Finalist | The Von Bulow Affair | William Wright | Delacorte Press |
| 1983 | Winner | The Vatican Connection | Richard Hammer | Holt, Rinehart and Winston |
| 1983 | Finalist | Big Bucks | Ernest Tidyman | W. W. Norton |
| 1983 | Finalist | Deadly Intentions | William Randolph Stevens | Congdon and Weed |
| 1983 | Finalist | Indecent Exposure: A True Story of Hollywood and Wall Street | David McClintock | Unknown |
| 1983 | Finalist | Somebody is Lying: The Story of Doctor X. | Myron Farber | Doubleday |
| 1982 | Winner | The Sting Man | Robert W. Greene | Dutton |
| 1982 | Finalist | By Reason of Doubt | Ellen Godfrey | Unknown |
| 1982 | Finalist | Papa's Game | Gregory Wallance | Unknown |
| 1982 | Finalist | The Day They Stole the Mona Lisa | Seymore V. Reit | Unknown |
| 1982 | Finalist | The Minds of Billy Milligan | Daniel Keyes | Random House |
| 1981 | Winner | A True Deliverance | Fred Harwell | Knopf |
| 1981 | Finalist | Assassination of Embassy Row | John Dinges, Saul Landeau | Pantheon |
| 1981 | Finalist | The Trial of Policeman Thomas Shea | Thomas Hawser | Viking |
| 1980 | Winner | The Falcon and the Snowman | Robert Lindsey | Simon & Schuster |
| 1980 | Finalist | Anyone's Daughter | Shana Alexander | Viking |
| 1980 | Finalist | Blood Will Tell | Gary Cartwright | Harcourt Brace Jovanovich |
| 1980 | Finalist | Sentenced to Die | Stephen H. Gettinger | Macmillan |
| 1980 | Finalist | Zebra | Clark Howard | Unknown |
| 1979 | Winner | Till Death Do Us Part | Vincent Bugliosi, Ken Hurwitz | W. W. Norton |
| 1979 | Finalist | Criminal Violence | Charles Silberman | Random House |
| 1979 | Finalist | Perjury | Alan Weinstein | Knopf |
| 1979 | Finalist | Why Have They Taken Our Children? | Jack W. Baugh, Jefferson Morgan | Delacorte Press |
| 1978 | Winner | By Persons Unknown | Barbara Amiel, George Jonas | Grove Press |
| 1978 | Finalist | Closing Time | Lacey Fosburgh | Delacorte Press |
| 1978 | Finalist | Justice Crucified | Roberta S. Feuerlicht | McGraw-Hill |
| 1978 | Finalist | Six Against the Rock | Clark Howard | Unknown |
| 1978 | Finalist | The Voice of Guns | Paul Avery, Vin McLellan | Unknown |
| 1977 | Winner | Blood and Money | Thomas Thompson | Doubleday |
| 1977 | Finalist | Murder in Coweta County | Margaret Anne Barnes | Unknown |
| 1977 | Finalist | The Michigan Murders | Edward Keyes | Unknown |
| 1976 | Winner | A Time To Die | Tom Wicker | Unknown |
| 1976 | Finalist | Invitation to a Lynching | Gene Miller | Doubleday |
| 1976 | Finalist | The House on Garibaldi Street | Isser Harel | Viking |
| 1975 | Winner | Helter Skelter | Vincent Bugliosi, Curt Gentry | W. W. Norton |
| 1975 | Finalist | Dummy | Ernest Tidyman | Little, Brown |
| 1975 | Finalist | The Memphis Murders | Gerald Meyer | Unknown |
| 1974 | Winner | Legacy of Death | Barbara Levy | Unknown |
| 1974 | Finalist | Burden of Proof | Ed Cray | Macmillan |
| 1974 | Finalist | The Implosion Conspiracy | Louis Nizer | Doubleday |
| 1974 | Finalist | The Medical Detectives | Paulette Cooper | Unknown |
| 1974 | Finalist | The Profession of Violence | John Pearson | Unknown |
| 1973 | Winner | Hoax | Lewis Chester, Stephen Fay, Magnus Linkletter | Viking |
| 1973 | Finalist | Shipwreck | Gordon Thomas, Max Morgan Witts | Unknown |
| 1973 | Finalist | The Santa Claus Bank Robbery | A.C. Greene | Knopf |
| 1973 | Finalist | They Got To Find Me Guilty Yet | T.P. Slattery | Doubleday |
| 1972 | Winner | Beyond A Reasonable Doubt | Sandor Frankel | Unknown |
| 1972 | Finalist | The Disappearence of Dr. Parkman | Robert Sullivan | Little, Brown |
| 1972 | Finalist | The Girl on the Volkswagen Floor | William A. Clark | Harper & Row |
| 1971 | Winner | A Great Fall | Mildred Savage | Simon & Schuster |
| 1971 | Finalist | Crime in America | Ramsey Clark | Orion |
| 1971 | Finalist | The Ninth Juror | Girard Chester | Random House |
| 1970 | Winner | The Case That Will Not Die | Herbert B. Ehrmann | Little, Brown |
| 1970 | Finalist | Scottsboro | Don T. Carter | LSU Press |
| 1970 | Finalist | The Victims | Kenneth Gross, Bernard Lefkowitz | Unknown |
| 1970 | Finalist | Whitmore | Fred C. Shapiro | Bobbs-Merrill |
| 1969 | Winner | Poe the Detective | John Evangelist Walsh | Rutgers University Press |
| 1969 | Finalist | The Mulberry Tree | John Frasca | Unknown |
| 1969 | Finalist | Three Sisters In Black | Norman Zierold | Little, Brown |
| 1968 | Winner | A Private Disgrace | Victoria Lincoln | Unknown |
| 1968 | Finalist | Black Market Medicine | Margaret Kreig | Unknown |
| 1968 | Finalist | Frame-Up | Curt Gentry | W. W. Norton |
| 1968 | Finalist | Justice in the Black Room | Selwyn Raab | World Publishing Company |
| 1967 | Winner | The Boston Strangler | Gerold Frank | Unknown |
| 1967 | Finalist | Crime and Detection | Julian Symons | Crown |
| 1967 | Finalist | The Last Two to Hang | Elwyn Jones | Unknown |
| 1966 | Winner | In Cold Blood | Truman Capote | Random House |
| 1966 | Finalist | A Little Girl is Dead | Harry Golden | World Publishing Company |
| 1966 | Finalist | Murderers Sane and Mad | Miriam Allen deFord | Unknown |
| 1966 | Finalist | The Century of the Detective | Jurgen Thorwald | Unknown |
| 1966 | Finalist | The Power of Life and Death | Lawrence G. Blochman, Michael V. DiSalle | Random House |
| 1965 | Winner | Gideon's Trumpet | Anthony Lewis | Random House |
| 1965 | Finalist | Lament for the Molly Maguires | Arthur H. Lewis | Unknown |
| 1965 | Finalist | The Honored Society | Norman Lewis | Unknown |
| 1965 | Finalist | The Minister and the Choir Singer | William Kunstler | Unknown |
| 1965 | Finalist | The Molly Maguires | Wayne G. Broehl Jr. | Harvard University Press |
| 1964 | Winner | The Deed | Gerold Frank | Simon & Schuster |
| 1964 | Finalist | Flight 967 | Brad Williams | Unknown |
| 1964 | Finalist | The Hired Killers | Peter Wyden | Unknown |
| 1963 | Winner | Tragedy in Dedham | Francis Russell | McGraw-Hill |
| 1962 | Winner | Death and the Supreme Court | Barrett Prettyman Jr. | Unknown |
| 1962 | Finalist | Kidnap | George Waller | Unknown |
| 1962 | Finalist | Lizzie Borden: The Untold Story | Edward D. Radin | Simon & Schuster |
| 1962 | Finalist | The Sheppard Murder Case | Paul Holmes | Unknown |
| 1961 | Winner | The Overbury Affair | Miriam Allen deFord | Unknown |
| 1961 | Finalist | Heaven Knows Who | Christianna Brand | Unknown |
| 1961 | Finalist | Mostly Murder | Sir Sydney Smith | Unknown |
| 1960 | Winner | Fire at Sea | Thomas Gallager | Unknown |
| 1960 | Finalist | Great Train Robberies of the West | Eugene B. Block | Unknown |
| 1959 | Winner | They Died in the Chair | Wenzell Brown | Unknown |
| 1959 | Finalist | The Deadly Reasons | Edward D. Radin | Unknown |
| 1959 | Finalist | The Incurable Wound | Berton Roueche | Little, Brown |
| 1959 | Finalist | The Murder and the Trial | Edgar Lustgarten | Unknown |
| 1959 | Finalist | The Royal Vultures | Hillel Black | Pocket Books |
| 1958 | Winner | The D.A.'s Man | Harold R. Danforth, James D. Horan | Crown |
| 1958 | Finalist | Memoirs of a Bow Street Runner | Henry Goddard, Patrick Pringle | Unknown |
| 1958 | Finalist | The Girl in the Belfry | Joseph Henry Jackson, Lenore Glen Offord | Unknown |
| 1957 | Winner | Night Fell on Georgia | Charles Samuels, Louise Samuels | Unknown |
| 1957 | Finalist | Historical Whodunits | Hugh Ross Williamson | Macmillan |
| 1957 | Finalist | Ruby McCollum, The Woman in the Suwanne Jail | William Bradford Huie | Dutton |
| 1956 | Winner | Dead and Gone | Manly Wade Wellman | University of North Carolina Press |
| 1956 | Finalist | The Assassins | Robert J. Donovan | Harper |
| 1956 | Finalist | The Truth About Belle Gunness | Lillian de la Torre | Unknown |
| 1955 | Winner | The Girl with the Scarlet Brand | Charles Boswell, Lewis Thompson | Unknown |
| 1954 | Winner | Why Did They Kill? | John Bartlow Martin | Ballantine Books |
| 1953 | Winner | Court of Last Resort | Erle Stanley Gardner | Unknown |
| 1952 | Winner | True Tales from the Annals of Crime and Rascality | St. Clair McKelway | Random House |
| 1952 | Finalist | Lady: Killers | W.T. Brannon | Unknown |
| 1951 | Winner | Twelve Against Crime | Edward D. Radin | Unknown |
| 1950 | Winner | Bad Company | Joseph Henry Jackson | Unknown |
| 1948 | Winner | Twelve Against the Law | Edward D. Radin | Unknown |